Mint chocolate Baileys ice cream

A green glass bowl of ice cream on a wooden board with a blue ice cream scoop and a bottle of Baileys.

Now, any number of things great and small can, and are currently, making the world feel off-kilter. Realising it had been a long, long time since I’d made ice cream was one such indicator for me, personally. Or at least, it was an indicator I could control. I appreciate this might not be the most relatable self-reassuring activity—but let me reassure you, when it comes to this mint chocolate Baileys ice cream, the method is simple, the flavour is dazzling. And, as we approach Christmas, there’s a certain seasonal heedlessness to these ingredients that feels right, right now. Need I remind you that I’ve never once capitulated to Big Ice Cream Machine and nor should you; despite this long-held stance this is perhaps the most ripplingly velvety-smooth ice cream I’ve made yet; I may just have struck the perfect chord of sugar, cocoa butter, and freeze-resistant alcohol.

Also: I am posting this, probably STUPIDLY, while in the middle of moving house with my partner; this ice cream was the last recipe I took photos of in the apartment I’ve lived in for three years and I wanted to symbolically (but also literally) close that off before starting anew in our new digs. You can, of course, guess what time of day this was primarily written.

Back to the ice cream: The thing about peppermint is that it’s so viciously, abrasively icy that it can weirdly make sense, through sheer force of will, in places where it shouldn’t necessarily align. In this case, breezing its way through the plush, vanilla-whisky backdrop of Baileys. And yet, make sense it does (and I freely admit, the “mint” and “Baileys” have been a natural pair in my head since I first saw the Gavin and Stacey Christmas special at the impressionable and formative age of 33—it is, irrevocably, what it is.)

Here, the peppermint is also softened and mellowed by the presence of white chocolate—a subtle yet necessary presence. There’s vanilla and cocoa already there in the Baileys: adding the white chocolate is like putting on reading glasses on your tastebuds before wading in.

But! You’ll also notice that the peppermint is included in not-enormous quantities; and somewhat muffled by the snowfall of icing sugar and all that cream. I wanted it noticeable without toothpaste-ily overpowering the Baileys or the chocolate—a mere 1/2 teaspoon is enough. I am not someone who’s reaching for a nip of Baileys on a regular basis (except for at Christmas, where it suddenly becomes alluringly delicious) but here its flavour really is unbeatable, my only choice in fact.

This is, despite the inclusion of inelegant Baileys and the least credible of the chocolate family, an opulent ice cream with surprising complexity unfolding in each soft mouthful. I’ve always thought that ice cream was one of the finest mediums for conveying flavour; this recipe is yet another affirmation that I’m incredibly correct in this stance.

Given the aforementioned beginning-to-look-a-lot-like-Christmas-ness of the ingredients, this could be an ideal and low-stress (or at least, you can and must make it ahead) dessert option leading up to or on Christmas. You could make it alongside this equally easy Brandy Snap Ice Cream and the admittedly more laborious Cranberry Curd Ripple Ice Cream for a real seasonal scoop experience. For more explorations of peppermint, however, I suggest:

Mint chocolate Baileys ice cream [no-churn]

This really is an alchemical combination; perhaps my most velvety-smooth no-churn ice cream yet. As for the flavour: it’s right there in the title, of COURSE it’s utterly delicious. As always, before shopping for these or any ingredients, I recommend checking out the Boycott Aotearoa zines so you know which brands to avoid. Recipe by myself.

  • 150g white chocolate
  • 500ml cream
  • 100g icing sugar
  • 1/4 teaspoon fine sea salt
  • 1/2 teaspoon peppermint essence
  • 5 tablespoons Baileys

1: Roughly chop the 150g white chocolate and place in a small heatproof bowl. Heat 100ml of the cream in a mini pan, until small bubbles just start to appear around the edges and the surface. As soon as this happens, pour the hot cream over the chopped chocolate and let it sit for a minute before stirring into a loose ganache. Stir in the 1/4 teaspoon salt, and set aside to cool.

2: Whisk or whip the remaining 400ml cream in a large bowl until floppily thickened—just enough that you can move the whisk through the cream and its prongs rake through a visible trail that holds before subsiding—if that makes sense. Scatter in the 100g icing sugar and whisk again to combine. Basically, you don’t want completely whipped cream here, but you need to get it genuinely thickened with some structural heft.

3: Anyway, that’s enough explaining—you’re nearly done—once the white chocolate has cooled down, fold it gently into the thickened cream along with the 1/2 teaspoon of peppermint essence and 5 tablespoons of Baileys. The alcohol might un-thicken the cream slightly, give it a good whisk and it should spring back.

4: Spatula this into a freezer-proof lidded container and, indeed, freeze for six hours or until solid. I always like to leave the unfrozen mixture to develop for a few hours in the fridge first, but I don’t have any side-by-side tests to prove it does anything significant.

Makes just under 1 litre.

what I’ve been listening to lately:

SavageMorning by The De Codas—my dad’s band—their latest song is not only written by Dad, the music video is also completely filmed, directed and edited by him as well. I am proud of the toil and the breadth of cinematic quality involved. Video aside, the song is great, with a kind of sloping, R.E.M-ish melancholy to the verses balanced by a smoothly catchy chorus. Go check it out!

Could We Start Again Please? from Jesus Christ Superstar, performed here by Margaret Urlich and Tim Beveridge of the 1994 New Zealand cast; a production that had an enormous impact upon me—this is simply one of the greatest renditions of this song, with Margaret Urlich’s voice like two silver coins rubbing together (I’ve used this simile before but it remains true), and Tim Beveridge’s confident bellow and the way they blend together like peppermint essence and Baileys; I saw the recent touring production of this show and it was SPECTACULAR, but for one crucial detail: their Peter cruelly opted down on “halt” not once but twice in this very song. Unfathomable! Luckily, there’s this version to remind me what perfection sounds like: opting up on both “halt” instances, the second time more dramatically. (I adore the film adaptation but even that one tests my patience with one opt-down and one opt-up.)

I’m on Fire by Catherine Elicson, I stumbled across this and it’s so good that I think you should just listen to it immediately without me giving any leading similes or metaphors.

PS: Feeling hopeless is a luxury that serves no one but those perpetrating the hopelessness, despite the hopelessness being accelerated beyond comprehension daily. The people of Palestine need us now more than ever; aside from directly sending money when you see personal videos pop up as you scroll, you can support:

  • ReliefAid’s Gaza Appeal, who are connected with teams on the ground in Gaza.
  • Convoys of Good, another registered NZ charity distributing aid.
  • Please visit Chuffed—they’re one of the few spaces providing families in Palestine with official crowd-funding platforms, as well as for other urgent causes.
  • As I’ve already mentioned, you can also demonstrate your control and power through the absence of your dollars. Boycott Zine Aotearoa has helpfully put together two comprehensive free zines so you can quickly see who to studiously avoid when buying food, drinks, household items and beauty products.
  • You can also check out the Pro-Palestine Business Aotearoa account by the same people for a very solid list of places to actively focus your consumer attention on.
The message "If you're not pro-palestine don't read my food blog" in red font against a light pink background.

Leave a Reply